
Which handlebar tape should you choose?
Every road cyclist, whether riding a classic or a modern bike, eventually asks which tape to use. Black is an easy answer. It always works. 🙂
Once you start considering colour and material, the choice gets much bigger. The right tape can improve the look of a bike and make it your own. The wrong tape can do the opposite.
Plenty of riders have put a great deal of care into a restoration and then been disappointed by the choice of tape. Here is a little history to make the decision easier.
Types of handlebar tape
Cotton and other cloth tapes were used into the 1970s. Riders often coated them with shellac for better weather and dirt resistance. Here is an example of classic cloth tape, still available in several colours and a great choice for a period build.

Plastic tape appeared in the 1970s. Benotto is probably the best-known example, although Shiny Tape and AGU also sold it.
Benotto is still popular for bikes from that period. People also use it on bikes from other eras because it looks so good. It came in a smooth version and a textured version for better grip.
Benotto once came in a huge range of colours. I often heard that cycling shops sold it for two German marks in almost any colour. I could still buy it for around five euros before the 2020s. At the time of writing it was usually well over ten euros, and the selection was often limited to basic colours or unusual leftovers as old stocks dwindled.
Examples of Benotto, AGU Sport and Shiny Tape:

Up to that point, grip and appearance were generally the main considerations.
Many more materials followed, along with higher expectations. Tape was expected to cushion bumps, grip in the wet and feel comfortable even without gloves. Gloves can still improve grip and protect your hands in a fall.
Appearance still matters, but comfort and control come first. On a long ride the tape can make the difference between an enjoyable ride and aching hands. It should also grip when wet with rain or sweat.
Different materials suit different needs. Here is an overview.
Polyurethane (PU)
PU is a versatile and popular choice. It grips well even when wet, cleans easily and resists wear. Composite tapes combine two materials. The ones I favour use PU over a cork or EVA base, bringing together the grip and easy cleaning of PU and the cushioning of cork or EVA. The example below is a multicolour PU and EVA tape.
Multicolour PU and EVA handlebar tape

EVA foam
EVA foam is light, soft and excellent at absorbing shocks, though it is harder to clean. Combining it with a PU surface gives you the advantages of both. Pure EVA can look attractive in the package but bulky once wrapped.
Cork
Natural cork tape feels a little smoother than EVA. It picks up dirt and can be difficult to clean, and it may tear if wrapped too tightly. Camouflage tapes around the turn of the millennium are a familiar example.
Leather
Leather is still used, mostly on high-end classic road bikes. It is often stitched around the bar, although Brooks has offered leather tape you can wrap. It cannot match the grip and comfort of some modern materials, but stitched leather has a look of its own.
Silicone
Silicone is comfortable and offers good grip. It is usually a little more expensive than other tapes and is a good alternative to PU and EVA.
Those are some of the materials you will find on the market.
Ease of wrapping also varies. PU and EVA composites and silicone are less likely to tear if you pull a little harder. Social media videos that make it look as if you can throw the tape around the bars from a distance are misleading. Wrap it carefully. The bars are one of your most important points of contact with the bike.
Verdict. For most road cyclists, PU and EVA or silicone are the best choices.
That is a short answer, but it may be all a rider with bare handlebars needs to know. 🙂
The shop carries several handlebar tapes. The original German article noted that weekday orders placed by 1 p.m. usually arrived the next day, excluding weekends and public holidays. If you have questions, you can reach us using the contact information on the site.